Not legal, tax, or accounting advice. This is a broker's explanation of how key money deals usually work in practice. Every one of these deals should be papered by a New York attorney, and your accountant should look at how the price is allocated. All dollar figures below are made up to show the math, not market prices.

If you've looked at second-generation restaurant spaces in New York City, you've probably seen a listing that says something like "key money: $150,000" or "asking for key money." It's one of the most common, and most misunderstood, numbers in a NYC restaurant deal.

In plain English: key money is what you pay the outgoing restaurant operator to step into their space instead of starting from scratch. It isn't rent and it isn't a deposit. Once it's paid, it's gone.

Paying it can be a smart move. A working kitchen can save you months of construction and a lot of money. But you're paying for things you can't fully see, under a lease you didn't negotiate, with a landlord who hasn't approved you yet. Here's how to look at it.

What key money actually buys

Most of the time, key money is paid by the incoming operator to the outgoing operator. What you get for it depends on the deal, but it usually comes from some mix of these:

  • The infrastructure. Hood and exhaust, ductwork, fire suppression, gas service, grease interceptor, walk-ins, plumbing, electrical capacity. In NYC, venting and gas alone can decide whether a space can be a restaurant at all. A space that already has them is worth more.
  • The equipment and furniture (often called FF&E): ranges, fryers, refrigeration, dish machine, tables, chairs, bar.
  • The lease. If the existing lease has a below-market rent, years left on the term, and renewal options, taking it over can be worth real money. If the rent is at market and there's only a short term left, it's worth much less.
  • The approvals and history. An existing Place of Assembly certificate, a C of O that already allows eating and drinking, and a space with a track record of passing inspections.
  • Time. Every month you don't spend building is a month you're not paying rent on a construction site.
  • Sometimes the business itself: the name, recipes, phone number, social accounts, and goodwill, if you're buying the restaurant as a going concern rather than just the space.

Be clear about which of these you're buying. "Key money for the space" and "buying the restaurant" are two different deals, with different diligence and different paperwork.

The landlord controls the deal

This is the part first-time buyers underestimate. The outgoing tenant can't hand you the space on their own. Taking over their lease is an assignment, and almost every NYC restaurant lease requires the landlord's consent to an assignment. Sometimes the landlord would rather sign a new lease directly with you. Either way, nothing works without the landlord.

When you show up, the landlord will look at you the way they'd look at any new tenant. Expect them to ask for:

  • Your own personal guaranty. Usually a good-guy guaranty, and usually with the same structure as a new deal: you guarantee the full lease for the first year or two, and only after that does the good-guy protection kick in. See our guide to Personal Guarantees and Good-Guy Clauses.
  • Your own security deposit. The outgoing tenant's deposit is theirs to sort out with the landlord. Don't assume it transfers to you.
  • Financials, experience, and a business plan.
  • Sometimes a new lease or lease amendment, with new rent, a new term, or other changes. If the landlord uses the assignment to reset the rent, the lease you thought you were buying may not be the lease you get.

Why the landlord doesn't share in your key money (and doesn't want the seller to profit off the lease)

Landlords don't want their tenants making money by leasing their space. Most NYC leases give the landlord most or all of any profit a tenant makes on an assignment or sublet, meaning anything paid for the lease itself above the rent. Don't expect to negotiate a split of that profit. It's rarely on the table.

That's one reason key money deals are usually framed as a sale of the restaurant's assets or business (equipment, improvements the tenant owns, goodwill), not a payment "for the lease." How the price is described and allocated matters to the landlord, to the seller, and to your taxes. That's a job for the attorneys and your accountant, not something to improvise on a term sheet. Read the assignment section of the existing lease early, because it tells you what the landlord can claim.

How key money is negotiated

There's no formula, and asking prices are often set by what the seller needs, not by what the space is worth. Here's how I'd think about the number.

1. Price it against building it yourself

Ask your architect, engineer, or contractor what it would cost and how long it would take to build what's already there: venting, gas, the grease interceptor, walk-ins, ADA bathrooms, and so on. Add the rent you'd pay during that extra construction time. That's roughly the ceiling on what the infrastructure is worth to you, and only if it's in working order and suits your concept.

2. Value the lease honestly

Compare the existing rent, escalations, and remaining term against what you'd pay for a comparable space. A long term at a below-market rent is valuable. A lease with two years left and no renewal option may be close to worthless, or a liability. And remember that the landlord may change the terms when they consent.

3. Discount for what you'll replace

If you're going to rip out the bar, replace the line, or reconfigure the dining room, the existing FF&E isn't worth much to you. Equipment that's old, leased, or financed is worth less still. (Leased or financed equipment isn't the seller's to sell.)

4. Factor in the seller's situation

A seller who's still operating and profitable can wait. A seller who's already closed and paying rent on a dark space every month has a strong reason to make a deal. Neither one is a reason to skip diligence.

5. Negotiate the terms, not just the price

How you pay can matter as much as how much you pay:

  • Deposit into escrow, not to the seller. Your attorney (or the seller's) holds the deposit until closing.
  • Closing conditioned on landlord consent. If the landlord doesn't approve you on terms you accept, you get your deposit back. This is a normal condition in an assignment deal, and unlike a permit contingency in a lease, sellers generally expect it.
  • Payment at closing, against a signed assignment and the landlord's written consent.
  • A holdback for anything that's supposed to be fixed or delivered after closing.
  • An equipment list attached to the contract, with what's included, what's excluded, and what condition it has to be in.

Due diligence before you pay

Key money doesn't get you a free pass on diligence. If anything, you need more of it, because you're inheriting someone else's choices.

Can you get your permits?

The landlord almost certainly won't give you a permit contingency in the lease or the assignment, and the seller won't either. That means you need to confirm, before you sign, that the approvals your concept needs are realistic for this space: the C of O, Place of Assembly if you'll have 75 or more people, building permits for your changes, venting, gas, and a liquor license if you need one. Have your architect or expediter confirm it. If nobody can tell you it's doable, don't buy the space.

Is the infrastructure what it looks like?

Have the hood, exhaust, suppression system, gas, refrigeration, and plumbing inspected by people who know restaurant systems. "It works" and "it's legal and signed off" are different things. Check DOB records for open violations and permits that were never signed off.

What does the existing lease actually say?

Get the full lease and all amendments, not a summary. Read the use clause (see our guide to Use Clauses in NYC Restaurant Leases), the remaining term and renewal options, rent steps, the assignment section, and the restoration obligations at the end of the term. Check what the tenant pays toward the building's real estate taxes. In NYC restaurant leases the tenant pays its proportionate share of tax increases over a base year, and that bill comes with the lease you're taking over. If the space is in Manhattan below 96th Street, run the numbers on the Commercial Rent Tax too.

Is the seller current?

Ask the landlord for an estoppel certificate confirming the rent is paid, there are no defaults, and the lease documents you've seen are the complete lease. Unpaid rent or open defaults are the seller's problem to clear before closing, not yours after.

Sales tax: the bulk sale notice

If you're buying business assets from a seller who collected New York sales tax, the New York State Tax Department says the purchaser must file Form AU-196.10 at least 10 days before paying for or taking possession of the assets, whichever comes first. If you don't, you can be held personally liable for the seller's unpaid sales tax. Your attorney should handle this, but make sure someone does.

Liens and equipment ownership

Ask your attorney to search for liens (UCC filings) on the equipment and confirm what the seller actually owns free and clear.

Trash, utilities, and contracts

You'll hire your own private trash hauler. The landlord doesn't handle restaurant garbage, and under the City's Commercial Waste Zones program you contract with a carter authorized for your zone (DSNY). Find out which service contracts (carting, pest control, equipment leases, POS) the seller has, and don't take any over by accident.

If you're the one selling

Most of the same points apply in reverse:

  • Your guaranty may not go away. Many landlords won't release the original guarantor on an assignment, or only release you once the buyer posts their own guaranty and security. Ask the landlord early.
  • Don't count on profiting from the lease itself. The landlord will likely keep most or all of any assignment profit. Price what you actually own: the equipment, the improvements you own, and the business.
  • Know your exit costs. If the sale falls through and you leave using a good-guy clause instead, you'll almost always forfeit your security deposit, and you'll pay rent through the surrender date.

Frequently asked questions

Is key money paid to the landlord?

Usually not. In most NYC restaurant deals, key money goes to the outgoing operator for their equipment, improvements, and business. Landlords generally collect rent, a security deposit, and a guaranty, not key money. If a landlord is asking for a separate payment, ask your attorney what it is and how it's documented.

Is key money refundable?

No. Once the deal closes, key money is a purchase price, not a deposit. That's why the deposit should sit in escrow and closing should depend on the landlord's consent.

Does key money reduce my rent?

No. You still pay full rent, real estate tax escalations, and everything else in the lease. Key money buys you what's already in the space and, sometimes, a lease with better terms than you'd get today.

Can I get a permit contingency in a key money deal?

Rarely. Neither the landlord nor the seller usually wants their deal to depend on your permits. Confirm permit feasibility with your architect or expediter before you sign anything.

Should I sign the purchase agreement before the landlord approves me?

You can sign, but structure it so your deposit is held in escrow and closing depends on the landlord's written consent on terms you accept. Don't release money to the seller before then.

The bottom line

Key money can be the cheapest way into a working NYC restaurant, or a very expensive way to buy someone else's problems. Price it against what it would cost you to build, value the lease honestly, keep your money in escrow until the landlord signs off, and do all of your permit and infrastructure diligence before you commit. And go in assuming you'll be signing your own guaranty, posting your own deposit, and taking on the lease's tax escalations, just like any new tenant.


Get the free checklist: The NYC Restaurant Lease Red-Flag Checklist covers what to check on any space, including takeovers, before you sign. Get it here →

This article is general information, not legal, tax, or accounting advice, and doesn't create an attorney–client or other professional relationship. Talk to a New York attorney and your accountant about your specific deal. Eligible NYC small businesses can get free lease help through the City's Commercial Lease Assistance Program.