Not legal advice. This is a broker's explanation of how use clauses usually work in NYC restaurant deals. Have a New York commercial lease attorney review your lease, and have your architect or expediter confirm what the City will actually allow in the space.
The use clause is usually one short paragraph near the front of the lease. It's easy to skim past. It shouldn't be.
It decides what you're allowed to do in the space: what you can sell, whether you can serve alcohol, whether you can run delivery and catering, and how late you can stay open. It also decides how easy it will be to sell your business someday, because the next operator has to fit inside the same clause.
What a use clause is
The use clause (sometimes called the "permitted use" clause) says what the tenant may use the premises for, and usually adds "and for no other purpose." Anything that isn't listed is, at best, a gray area and, at worst, a default.
A narrow clause might read like this (illustrative only):
"Tenant shall use the premises solely for the operation of a Neapolitan pizza restaurant, and for no other purpose."
A broader one might read:
"Tenant shall use the premises for the operation of a full-service restaurant and bar, including the sale of food and beverages for on- and off-premises consumption, takeout, delivery, catering, the sale of related retail merchandise and packaged goods, and private events, and for any lawful use ancillary thereto."
Same space, very different leases.
Why landlords want it narrow
Landlords aren't being difficult for the fun of it. A tight use clause helps them:
- Protect other tenants' exclusives. If the landlord promised the coffee shop next door that no one else in the building would sell espresso drinks, your use clause has to respect that.
- Control the building. Especially in mixed-use buildings with apartments upstairs, landlords worry about odors, noise, late hours, and live music.
- Manage the tenant mix, in a retail center or a building where the ground floor is curated.
- Keep control over who comes next. A narrow use makes it harder for you to assign the lease to anyone the landlord didn't pick.
Knowing why they want it narrow helps you negotiate. You can usually address the real concern (a specific competitor, a specific noise issue) without accepting a clause that locks you into one menu forever.
What to ask for
Here's what I'd want in a restaurant use clause. Not every landlord will agree to all of it, so decide which ones matter most to your concept and put them in the LOI.
- Describe the use by category, not cuisine. "Restaurant" or "full-service restaurant and bar," not "Thai restaurant" or a specific menu. Concepts evolve. Menus change. A cuisine-specific clause can turn a menu change into a lease problem.
- Alcohol. If you'll ever want to serve beer, wine, or liquor, say so, and ask that the landlord cooperate with your State Liquor Authority application, including signing whatever the application requires.
- Takeout, delivery, and catering. These are now part of how most restaurants make money. List them.
- Retail and packaged goods. Merchandise, bottled sauces, baked goods to go.
- Private events, and live or recorded music if it's part of your concept.
- Hours. Make sure the lease (and any building rules) let you open and close when your concept needs to, including late nights if you're a bar.
- Outdoor dining, if the location allows it. The lease should let you apply, and the landlord should sign what the City requires.
- "Any lawful use ancillary to the foregoing." A small phrase that covers a lot of the gray areas.
- No operating covenant, or a reasonable one. Make sure you're not required to be open hours that don't work for you, and that you can close for renovations, holidays, and emergencies without being in default.
The use clause can't make a space legal
This is the part that catches first-time operators. The lease saying you can operate a restaurant doesn't mean the City says you can.
What you can actually do in the space depends on zoning, the building's Certificate of Occupancy, whether you need a Place of Assembly certificate (if you'll have 75 or more people indoors, per DOB), whether you can run venting and gas where you need them, landmarks rules, and, for alcohol, the State Liquor Authority's review. Many landlords will also write the use clause so that getting those approvals is your responsibility, at your cost.
And landlords very rarely agree to a permit contingency, a right to walk away if you can't get your approvals. So once you sign, the permit risk is yours. Confirm that what your concept needs is realistic for the space before you sign, with your architect, engineer, or expediter. If nobody can tell you it's doable, don't take the space.
Exclusives: yours and everyone else's
Two related things to check:
- Other tenants' exclusives. Ask the landlord for a list of exclusives already granted in the building or center. If your lease says you can't violate them, you need to know what they are before you write your menu.
- Your own exclusive. If your concept depends on not having a direct competitor next door, ask for an exclusive, define it tightly (what exactly is protected), and get a real remedy if the landlord breaks it, such as reduced rent or a right to terminate.
Prohibited uses and building rules
Also read:
- The lease's list of prohibited uses, which can quietly knock out things like a bar, a hookah lounge, or live entertainment.
- Building rules and regulations attached to the lease. These can control deliveries, trash storage, hours, and noise in ways the use clause doesn't mention.
- Nuisance clauses about odors, noise, and vibration. In a building with apartments upstairs, make sure normal restaurant operations can't be called a default.
On trash in particular: you'll hire your own private trash hauler. The landlord doesn't handle restaurant garbage, and under the City's Commercial Waste Zones program you contract with a carter authorized for your zone (DSNY). Make sure the lease allows somewhere to store garbage, recycling, and organics between pickups.
How the use clause affects your exit
Most restaurant owners don't think about selling when they sign the lease. They should. When you eventually sell your restaurant, the buyer usually takes over your lease, and the buyer has to fit inside your use clause.
A clause that says "Neapolitan pizza restaurant" limits your buyers to people who want to run a Neapolitan pizza restaurant. A clause that says "restaurant and bar" lets you sell to almost any operator. That can make a real difference to what your business is worth, and to how much a buyer will pay in key money.
Keep in mind that the landlord will still have to consent to the assignment, and will likely keep most or all of any profit on the lease itself. So the value you're protecting is the value of your business: the buildout, equipment, and goodwill. Read more in our guide to Personal Guarantees and Good-Guy Clauses, which covers what happens to your guaranty in a sale.
Use clause and percentage rent
Percentage rent isn't common in NYC restaurant leases; most deals here are fixed base rent with annual escalations. If your lease does have percentage rent, the use clause and the definition of "gross sales" work together. Adding catering, delivery, or retail to your use can also add those sales to what you owe the landlord a percentage of. Read the two clauses side by side.
Frequently asked questions
Can I change my menu if my use clause names a cuisine?
Maybe not without the landlord's consent. If the clause names a specific cuisine or concept, a significant change could be a default. That's why it's better to describe the use by category ("restaurant") in the first place.
Does a broad use clause mean I can open a bar?
Not by itself. The lease is only one layer. Zoning, the Certificate of Occupancy, Place of Assembly rules, and a State Liquor Authority license all have to line up too. Confirm feasibility before you sign.
Will the landlord give me a permit contingency if my use needs approvals?
Rarely. Most landlords won't let your lease depend on your permits. Do the feasibility work with your architect or expediter before you sign.
Should delivery and catering be in my use clause?
If there's any chance you'll do them, yes. Adding them later means asking the landlord for an amendment, and you'll have less leverage then than you do before you sign.
Does the use clause matter if I never plan to sell?
Yes. It controls what you can do day to day, how your concept can evolve, and what happens if you ever need to sell or bring in a partner. Plans change.
The bottom line
Ask for the broadest use clause the landlord will accept: restaurant and bar, with takeout, delivery, catering, retail, and events, described by category rather than cuisine. Find out what other tenants' exclusives and the building rules already prohibit. And remember that the lease can't make a space legal. Confirm that the City will allow your concept in the space before you sign, because you probably won't get a permit contingency.
Get the free checklist: The NYC Restaurant Lease Red-Flag Checklist covers use clauses, exclusives, and 80+ other things to check before you sign. Get it here →
This article is general information, not legal advice, and doesn't create an attorney–client or other professional relationship. Talk to a New York commercial lease attorney about your specific lease. Eligible NYC small businesses can get free lease help through the City's Commercial Lease Assistance Program.
Get the free NYC Restaurant Lease Red-Flag Checklist
80+ things to check before you sign a letter of intent or a lease in New York City, from the C of O and venting to guaranties, tax escalations, and assignment rights.
One email with the checklist, then occasional NYC restaurant leasing notes. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.